Preliminary preliminary agreement and breach: between earnest money and contractual liability
Summary
The Court of Palermo analyzes the validity of the preliminary preliminary agreement and the breach that justifies withdrawal with the return of double the earnest money (caparra).
Key Points
- Validity of the progressive formation of the contractual bond (so-called preliminary preliminary agreement) according to legitimate jurisprudence.
- Qualification of obstructionism in the stipulation of the preliminary agreement as a serious breach of good faith obligations.
- Right to double the earnest money even if the check delivered was not materially cashed by the seller.
- Centrality of the principle of fairness and good faith in the intermediate phases of real estate negotiation.
Comment by Avv. Donatella Conicella – Head of the Civil Law Department of Legal Aid
Sentence n. 226/2025 of the Court of Palermo, issued by Dr. Sara Monteleone, addresses a particularly relevant issue regarding earnest money (caparra confirmatoria) in the context of a real estate contract characterized by a progressive formation of the contractual bond (so-called preliminary preliminary agreement).
1. RECONSTRUCTION OF THE CONTRACTUAL RELATIONSHIP
The parties had signed a purchase proposal (23.6.2021) accepted by both co-owners of the property, with the provision of:
- a sale price of 580,000.00 euros;
- the immediate payment of 20,000.00 euros as earnest money (caparra confirmatoria);
- the subsequent stipulation of a preliminary contract by 30.9.2021;
- the final contract by 31.1.2022.
2. THE PROBLEM THAT AROSE
The promising seller (Adamo) repeatedly hindered the stipulation of the preliminary contract, raising issues related to leasing financing and the need for building modifications (a plasterboard wall) for the change of intended use. Despite expressing consent to the draft prepared by the Notary, she repeatedly evaded meetings scheduled for the stipulation.
3. JUDICIAL LEGAL ASSESSMENT
The Court:
- recognizes the validity of the multi-phase contractual structure, referring to legitimate jurisprudence (Cass. S.U. 4628/2015 and Cass. 12527/2018);
- qualifies the accepted proposal as a preliminary preliminary agreement, subject to contractual good faith;
- finds a serious breach by the promising seller, for having initially expressed consent to the stipulation, then pretextually raised obstacles and omitted any useful collaboration for the conclusion of the agreement.
4. EARNEST MONEY (CAPARRA CONFIRMATORIA) AND WITHDRAWAL
In application of art. 1385, co. 2, c.c., the Court recognizes the right of the purchasing party (Ro.Gi. S.r.l.) to withdraw from the contract and to obtain double the earnest money (caparra) paid (20,000.00 euros), even though the check had not been cashed by the seller. According to the orientation of the Cassation (sent. 19801/2021), the effect of the earnest money (caparra) is perfected with the delivery and availability of the title, even if not collected.
5. SYSTEMIC OBSERVATIONS
The sentence exemplarily highlights:
- contractual good faith as a criterion for judging breach;
- the functional role of earnest money (caparra confirmatoria) as a tool for compensatory self-protection;
- the inapplicability of the notice to perform (diffida ad adempiere) ex art. 1454 c.c. in the presence of subsequent behaviors incompatible with the expressed resolutive will.
CONCLUSIONS
The decision is in line with the most authoritative legitimate jurisprudence and constitutes a well-reasoned example of the application of the regime of earnest money (caparra confirmatoria) and the discipline of contracts with progressive formation. It reinforces the centrality of the principle of fairness and good faith even in contractual relationships not yet perfected in their definitive form.
Content drafted with the support of artificial intelligence tools and reviewed by the firm’s lawyers. More information
Attached Documents
Legal Aid Italia
Ha letto l'articolo e ha bisogno di assistenza?
Lo Studio Legal Aid è a disposizione per una consulenza riservata. Risposta garantita entro 24 ore.
Legal Insight
Altri articoli dello Studio
Opporsi all'estradizione: i timori non bastano, servono allegazioni
Cass. pen. 34698/2026: per opporsi all'estradizione servono elementi specifici su titolo, specialità e condizioni detentive. Cosa produrre e quando.
LeggiFrode fiscale e società schermo: l'insuccesso degli affari non prova la fittizietà
Cass. pen. 34605/2026: annullata la condanna per frode fiscale basata su società «scatole vuote» e dichiarazioni di consulenti interessati. Cosa cambia.
LeggiAmministratore di diritto e amministratore di fatto: il confine tra concorso consapevole e responsabilità di posizione nella bancarotta fraudolenta
Cass. pen. 33583/2026: l'amministratore di fatto non trasforma quello di diritto in una testa di legno. Generica consapevolezza, dolo eventuale e difesa.
Leggi